Tax Case

3092 words 13 pages
TAXATION LAW

INTERNAL ASSIGNMENT – II

Case Analysis: R.S. Joshi, STO, Gujarat & Ors. Vs. Ajit Mills Ltd & Anr.

Citation: AIR1977SC2279

Prof-in-charge: Prof Ashutosh Naik

By-

Swathi. A.P

III BBA LLB ‘A’

Roll No. 23

Symbiosis Law School

Ph: 7798627663

Name of the case:

R.S. Joshi, STO, Gujarat & Ors. Vs. Ajit Mills Ltd & Anr.

Citation:

AIR 1977 SC 2279: (1977) 4 SCC 98: 1977 SCC (Tax) 536

Decided On:
31.08.1977
Bench:
7 Judge Bench consisting of the following Justices of the Supreme Court of India:
Chief Justice M. Hameedullah Beg., Justice N. L. Untwalia, Justice P. N. Bhagwati, Justice P. S. Kailasam, Justice S. Murtaza Fazal Ali, Justice V. R. Krishna Iyer and Justice Y. V. Chandrachud.

Brief facts
…show more content…
All real punitive measures, including the dissuasive penalty of confiscating the excess collections, are valid, being within the range of ancillary powers of the legislature competent to exact a sales tax levy. The punitive impost in Section 37 (1) (a) is therefore legitimate and valid. If we accept this test, the appeals must succeed, so far as this point is concerned.
In the present case, the narrow issue is as to whether the forfeiture clause in Section 37(1) is bad because of the besetting sin of colourability. If it is a punitive measure to protect public interest in the enforcement of the fiscal legislation, it falls squarely within the area of implied powers.

The court went into the true character of a forfeiture. The court held that if it is penal, it falls within implied powers. If it is an act of mere transference of money from the dealer to the State, then it falls outside the legislative entry.

Speaking generally and having in mind the object of Section 37 read with Section 46, the court was inclined to the view that forfeiture has a punitive impact. Black's Legal Dictionary states that 'to forfeit' is 'to lose, or lose the right to, by some error, fault, and offence or crime, to incur a penalty.' 'Forfeiture', as judicially annotated, is 'a punishment annexed by law to some illegal act or negligence. . . .'; 'something imposed as a punishment for

Related

  • CGA-Tax Assignment
    1579 words | 7 pages
  • Tax Research Project
    3491 words | 14 pages
  • Tax Research
    1070 words | 5 pages
  • Income Tax Chapter 6
    13668 words | 55 pages
  • Lower Corporate Tax
    2267 words | 10 pages
  • Tax Research
    929 words | 4 pages
  • John Smith Tax Issues
    1384 words | 6 pages
  • Case Study of “Rigorous or Not?: a Case of Auditor Judgment for Deferred Tax Issues”
    2156 words | 9 pages
  • Introduction to Tax Residence
    14937 words | 60 pages
  • Tax Research Paper: Maxims of Tax Planning and Six Steps of Tax Research
    2118 words | 9 pages