# Great Lake

2142 words 9 pages
GREAT LAKES PIPE & TUBE, INC. “If we do decide to produce the 10- and 12-inch pipe internally, it could solve our overstaffing problem,” Mark Rubin, owner of Great Lakes Pipe & Tube, Inc. (GLPT), remarked to Vinny Patricko, the plant manager. “I’m reluctant to lay anyone off or even cut back hours. It’s not good business and it’s not the right thing to do if it can be at all avoided.”

THE FIRM Mark Rubin had no intentions of starting his own firm in 1972. Since graduating from college in 1964, he had worked for ML Pipe, a company based in Youngstown, Ohio. In January 1972, the company decided to relocate to New Jersey, and Rubin went also. Rubin and his wife were quite unhappy in Virginia, mainly because they felt

For the purpose of analysis, Rubin will assume straight-line depreciation to zero salvage value over the eight-year life of the project. (Ideally, you should use MACRS depreciation). The market value of the equipment after eight years is expected to be \$180,000 before taxes.

THE ACCOUNTANT’S ESTIMATES

The firm’s accountant, Abe Komansky, has developed a set of numbers that, in his view, “strongly indicates” in-house production is a “losing proposition.” (See Exhibit 2.) Komansky estimates it will cost 54.3 cents per pound to produce the 10-inch and 12-inch pipe internally. He notes that GLPT can purchase the same pipe for 45 cents per pound from another manufacturer and incurs another 2 cents per pound to get the pipe to GLPT’s customers. Thus, Komansky argues, internal production results in an 7.3 cent per pound loss, or \$87,600 per year assuming 1.2 million pounds of pipe.

As Rubin scans these figures, he smiles as he notices that Komansky used Rubin’s sales estimates and annual sales probabilities. He wonders, though, how accurate the accountant’s numbers really are. For one thing, the estimates are based on the “most likely” sales figure and do not consider the other sales possibilities. In addition, Rubin questions the appropriateness of including depreciation, given that it is a non-cash item. For these and other reasons, he decides to rethink the figures the

## Related

• ###### Case 1: Cj Industries and Heavey Pumps
1858 words | 8 pages
• ###### The Millennial Reign of Christ
5547 words | 23 pages
• ###### Test: History of Michigan
2327 words | 10 pages
• ###### Cuyahoga River
945 words | 4 pages
• ###### Glacier and Citrus College Chapter
4638 words | 19 pages
• ###### Cj Industries and Heavey Pumps – Discussion Questions
967 words | 4 pages
• ###### Acid Rain Pollution
3204 words | 13 pages
• ###### Clean Water Act
2403 words | 10 pages
• ###### Holes Essay
1594 words | 7 pages
• ###### Holes Essay- Fate V/S Free Will
1592 words | 7 pages