Dd303 “the Way We Speak Determines How We Think”. Critically Evaluate This Statement, Drawing on the Key Theories and Research That Describe the Relationship Between Language and Thought

2179 words 9 pages
Option 1

“The way we speak determines how we think”. Critically evaluate this statement, drawing on the key theories and research that describe the relationship between language and thought.

Language has traditionally been characterized by Philosophers as a cognitive tool used to freely externalize ones thoughts (Green, 2010 as cited in Kaye, 2010). The relationship between language, thought, culture and reality has occupied the minds of many for centuries. Early theorists argued that language and thought were two separate systems which “enter into an array of interconnected cognitive structures” (Chomsky, 1983). Extreme nativists and constructivists are key proponents of innateness and argued that knowledge and
…show more content…
He also explains how new or complex concepts are developed (.i.e. ipad) by decomposition into their basic elemental components. From this, it would suggest that language develops from already pre-existing concepts or thoughts which would show the directional flow of influence to come from thought rather than speech.

Chomsky (2006) is also a staunch proponent for the nativist approach and offers complimentary ideas to Fodor’s (1983) theory on innateness. He argued that the syntax of language is innate and that a universal grammar underpins language. The theory suggested that linguistic ability manifests itself without being taught, and that there are properties that all natural human languages share (Chomsky, 2006). Exploration of this hypothesis focused on word order, structure and parameters. Universally the random order of words differs amongst cultures. For example in English we use subject-verb-object language compared with those in Japanese who use Subject-Object-Verb. Chomsky (2006) argued that although the mental grammar differs from language to language, the process by which certain sentences are perceived as correct while others are not is universal and independent of meaning. He also argued that language acquisition is obtained through an innate language acquisition device. His theory later evolved into principles and parameters theory and looked at the abstract rules applied when learning a language. One of the key


  • Describe and Evaluate Bowlby’s Monotropic Theory
    1111 words | 5 pages
  • Critically Evaluate the Classical and Human Relations Approaches of Management Theory
    1670 words | 7 pages
  • How Social Schemas Theory and Related Research Contributes to Our Understanding of the Way in Which People Evaluate and React in Their Social Environment
    1519 words | 7 pages
  • Describe and Evaluate Any Two Theories in Developmental Psychology
    1219 words | 5 pages
  • “the Relationship Between Counsellor and Client Is the Most Influential Factor in Whether Counselling ‘Works’”. Critically Discuss This Statement from the Perspective of at Least Three Approaches to Counselling.
    2063 words | 9 pages
  • Heredity Determines Personality.” (a) Build an Argument to Support This Statement. (B) Build an Argument Against This Statement.
    2771 words | 12 pages
  • Summary Communication Theory
    13085 words | 53 pages
  • To What Extent Does Language Influence Thought?
    2719 words | 11 pages
  • How Social Networking Has Affected the Way We Work, Live, and Communicate
    1979 words | 8 pages
  • How important is that we are certain about what we claim as knowledge?
    1794 words | 8 pages