Birch Paper Company

1153 words 5 pages
1. The responsibility structure of the Birch Paper Company and all of its divisions is an Investment Centre. In the case it is stated that "for several years, each division had been judged on the basis of its profit and return on investment." This verifies that BPC's structure is an investment centre, since an investment center has a manager who is responsible for the division's profits as well as its invested capital. However, as stated in class, "some organizations use the terms profit centre and investment centre interchangeably," this is evident by the managers of BPC's divisions continually stressing profit as a major concern. As James Brunner, Thompson's division manager stated, "The division can't very well show a profit by …show more content…

6. The transfer pricing system is dysfunctional since it is possible for each internal division to price their product above the going market price. This ability for individual price setting deters the divisions from making purchases internally, although in the long run the company benefits from choosing, either internally or externally, the option with the lowest cost to the firm. If Thompson was persuaded to alter their sales cost from $480 to $430 this would make them one of the lowest bidders and intern Northern would be willing to accept their offer. This pricing change would allow Northern to go internally without the vice president's involvement. Shown below are a break-down of the out of pocket cost to Birch and the reduction of the contribution margin to Thompson.

THOMPSON $430 Less: Southern profit ($280*40%) $112 Thompson profit ($430-$400) 30 $142 Out of pocket cost to Birch $288

Although the Thompson division would lose some profit ($80-$30=$50), the price reduction still allows for the same out of pocket cost to Birch of $288. If the price was not changed Northern would have stayed with Western Paper Company resulting in an out of pocket cost to Birch of $430. The price change reflects a $142


  • Birch Paper
    1542 words | 7 pages
  • History of Psychology
    1425 words | 6 pages
  • Community Assessment
    5227 words | 21 pages
  • Neophyte
    11160 words | 45 pages
  • Bank of Queensland Research Paper Banking Industry
    21329 words | 86 pages