Organization Behavior: the Case of Julie and Susan

1285 words 6 pages
The Case of Julie and Susan

The case of Julie and Susan demonstrates how a breakdown in any component of the MARS Model affects individual behaviour and performance. The questions facing Dr. Griffiths are; how did this breakdown occur, and is there an effective way to fix it? Using organizational behaviour theories, it is possible to analyze the symptoms, problems, and causes. From this analysis, a recommendation on how best to fix the situation can be developed. Given the facts of the case, it is clear that the main problem is that, Julie and Susan do not have a clear understanding of each other’s expectations.

A symptom that has arisen from this problem is that Julie and Susan have engaged in a verbal
…show more content…
This is an internal factor that she has failed to consider as a result of self-serving bias. Susan essentially places all of the blame on Julie. Susan fails to consider that Julie may require additional time and feedback to successfully complete her work. Susan, like Julie, has fallen to self-serving bias by placing the blame on external factors and failing to consider internal factors that may have contributed to the situation. Dr. Griffiths needs to be aware that self-serving bias has played a role in the descriptions given by Julie and Susan. This awareness will allow Dr. Griffiths to differentiate the true cause of the problem from the causes given by Julie and Susan.
The main cause of the issue at hand is that Julie and Susan do not have an understanding of what each person expects of one another. Julie expects Susan to provide her with more time and feedback, while Susan expects Julie to finish her assigned work in the time given, without any additional feedback. This has led Susan to lack an understanding of her true role perception, given Julie’s expectations. At the same time, Julie has had to deal with external factors for which she was not prepared for, and that Susan feels Julie should be able to cope with, given the fact that Susan has no issue with the other secretaries. Taking this information as the cause of the conflict between Susan and Julie, Dr. Griffiths should follow the proceeding recommendation.



  • Susan Munro, Service Customer Analysis
    1658 words | 7 pages
  • Module 1– Case Mgt 501 Management and Organization Behavior
    1432 words | 6 pages
  • Org Behavior Case Study
    5325 words | 22 pages
  • Changing Behavior Case Study Analysis
    1033 words | 5 pages
  • Health Organization Case Study Research
    1502 words | 7 pages
  • Case Study : Struggling Operations in a Manufacturing Organization
    1397 words | 6 pages
  • Collective Behavior
    11908 words | 48 pages
  • Organization Behavior - 5 Case Studies with Answers
    7291 words | 30 pages
  • The Changing Workforce Is One of the Emerging Trends in Organizational Behavior. Describe How the Workforce Is Changing and Briefly Identify Two Consequences of These Changes for Organizations.
    873 words | 4 pages
  • Case of Analysis: Tarco Gmbh. Organization and Design
    1639 words | 7 pages